Should You Always Trust Science-Based Fitness Advice?
Gymgoers put a lot of stock in “science-based” fitness influencers, often changing their training based on their guru’s latest post. In many cases, however, an influencer’s hottest takes hinge on a single piece of research—and that’s shaky ground. In a new large-scale study published in Sports Medicine , 29 research teams tried to replicate 25 exercise science papers printed in leading journals between 2016 and 2021. They went to great lengths to match the original studies—recruiting participants with the same characteristics and using the same sample sizes, equipment, and procedures. They even asked the original authors for guidance when important details were missing or unclear (though few replied). Only 28% of the studies held up, and in 88% of those, the effects were far smaller than originally reported—about 75% smaller on average. The rest failed outright or were too muddled to interpret confidently. In other words, fewer than one in three exercise studies have reproducibl...